Discover the best New York Broadway shows of 2025. From iconic musicals to buzzy debuts, here’s your guide to Broadway’s hottest hits!
New York City’s theater scene isn’t just alive in 2025 — it’s absolutely unhinged in the best possible way. We’re talking rapping revolutionaries, bewitched roommates, lion kings, time portals, and enough jazz hands to make Bob Fosse blush.
Whether you’re a die-hard drama nerd, a Disney-loving day-tripper, or someone who just wandered in from Times Square looking for snacks, there’s a show with your name in blinking lights.
This isn’t just a roundup of the best Broadway shows in NYC — it’s your permission slip to laugh louder, cry harder, sing along (quietly), and leave the theater changed. Let’s raise the curtain. 🎭👇
Table of Contents
🎭 The Best New York Broadway Shows of 2025
(Broadway’s Never Been This Bold, Bizarre, or Bedazzled)
Looking for the best Broadway shows in New York in 2025? Here’s a lineup bursting with magic, music, mischief, and mayhem.
Whether you’re into epic tragedies, timeless Disney hits, or shows where everything falls apart, the current Broadway shows in NYC have something for every mood and moment.
✨ Wicked
The green girl is still defying gravity, eyeliner expectations, and emotional composure in 2025. Wicked on Broadway hasn’t lost a drop of its spellbinding power, and it continues to fly high as one of the best Broadway shows right now.
With fresh leads and updated staging, it’s perfect for both newcomers and lifelong Ozians. Bonus: Glinda’s sparkle budget is bigger than your rent.
Ideal for: First-time theatergoers, mother-daughter duos, and fans of morally complex witches.
🧑🎤 MJ The Musical
MJ The Musical moonwalks its way through Michael Jackson’s life and legendary hits with energy that can light up all of Times Square.
From Thriller to Smooth Criminal, the show’s choreography and vocals hit every beat. It’s one of the most electric Broadway shows in New York City right now, with enough sparkle to make you forget rent is due.
Ideal for: Moonwalkers, MJ superfans, and anyone who wants to yell “Hee-hee!” in public.
🧑🎤 Hell’s Kitchen
Alicia Keys brings her New York story to life in Hell’s Kitchen on Broadway. Mixing raw coming-of-age energy with powerhouse vocals, it’s the soulful anthem of 2025.
Expect poignant moments, street-savvy storytelling, and a soundtrack that will be on repeat for months.
Ideal for: Aspiring artists, local dreamers, and anyone who’s ever cried on the Q train.
🎭 Othello
Othello on Broadway returns with a modern edge and devastating intensity. This Shakespearean tragedy feels as urgent as ever in 2025, with themes of jealousy, race, and betrayal hitting harder than a drumline.
It’s one of the must-see dramatic Broadway shows in New York this season.
Ideal for: Literature lovers, drama students, and those who enjoy heartbreak in iambic pentameter.
💃 Chicago
Chicago on Broadway remains as sharp and sultry as ever, with murder, jazz, and fishnet tights galore.
The choreography slices through the stage like a stiletto, and the storyline reminds you that fame is fleeting — but razzle-dazzle is forever.
Ideal for: Sass queens, crime podcast fans, and people who use jazz hands unironically.
🧙 Harry Potter and the Cursed Child
The wizarding world grows up — but still forgets to bring a hairbrush. This magical epic makes spellcasting look Broadway-chic.
Harry Potter and the Cursed Child is full of stage magic and heart-pounding plot twists, and remains one of the most beloved NYC Broadway shows for families and Potterheads alike.
Ideal for: Hufflepuffs, magical dads, and those who say “Lumos” when turning on a flashlight.
🧚 Aladdin
Aladdin on Broadway is your golden ticket to flying carpets, pop-up palaces, and a genie that steals every scene.
The show delivers razzle-dazzle, mega vocals, and enough costume changes to shame your closet. It’s one of the most dazzling Broadway musicals for tourists and Disney fans alike.
Ideal for: Families, 90s kids, and hopeless romantics wishing on magic lamps.
🐈 The Lion King
Still the king of Broadway shows for families, The Lion King delivers jaw-dropping puppetry, unforgettable songs, and enough nostalgia to make even the most cynical adult sob.
With stunning visuals and a story that never grows old, it’s a roaring success year after year.
Ideal for: Kids, parents, and emotionally unstable adults pretending not to cry during the Circle of Life.
🎙️ Katsura Sunshine’s Rakugo
A comedic gem straight from Japan, Katsura Sunshine’s Rakugo is an offbeat, one-man storytelling show full of wit, warmth, and impeccable timing.
It’s one of the most charming off-Broadway shows in NYC, proving you don’t need fireworks to get a standing ovation.
Ideal for: Comedy lovers, Japanophiles, and fans of clever, minimalist theater.
📺 Stranger Things: The First Shadow
Dive into the upside-down with Stranger Things: The First Shadow, a theatrical prequel to the Netflix hit.
Expect eerie lighting, mind-bending effects, and 80s nostalgia so strong it might perm your hair. One of the new Broadway shows of 2025 with the highest buzz.
Ideal for: Sci-fi fans, Demogorgon hunters, and people who still own VHS tapes.
📻 Good Night, and Good Luck
A new dramatic musical based on the iconic Edward R. Murrow story, Good Night, and Good Luck captures the golden age of journalism and the high-stakes world of speaking truth to power.
A perfect addition to the lineup of serious, smart Broadway shows in 2025.
Ideal for: News junkies, free speech champions, and people who miss real journalism.
🕶️ The Play That Goes Wrong
If you think theater is all elegance and professionalism, The Play That Goes Wrong exists to prove you hilariously wrong.
Props fall, lines are forgotten, and chaos reigns in this physical comedy masterpiece. It’s still one of the funniest Broadway shows in NYC — even if half the set falls on you.
Ideal for: Comedy lovers, clumsy people, and aspiring actors with trauma.
🎭 Sunset Boulevard
Norma Desmond is ready for her close-up — again — and she’s more glamorous, unhinged, and musically melodramatic than ever.
This revival of Sunset Boulevard brings Hollywood noir to Broadway with dazzling visuals, sweeping orchestrations, and enough drama to make even TikTok seem low-key.
You’ll be rooting for her… and also slightly scared.
Ideal for: Classic film buffs, musical lovers, and anyone who secretly enjoys watching the fabulous unravel.
🎷 The Great Gatsby
The Great Gatsby on Broadway gives F. Scott Fitzgerald’s glittering tragedy the musical makeover it never knew it needed.
With roaring 20s glamour, heartbreak in song, and jazz that burns slow, it’s one of the most talked-about Broadway shows in New York this year.
Ideal for: Literature lovers, Gatsby groupies, and people still dreaming of that green light.
🎤 Hamilton
Still revolutionary, still rhyming circles around the Founding Fathers.
Hamilton on Broadway remains a top contender among the best Broadway shows in NYC, combining hip-hop with history in a way that’s both powerful and educational (without being boring — promise).
Ideal for: History buffs, rhyme nerds, and anyone with a Spotify playlist titled Founding Beats.
🌟 Gypsy
Step aside, stage moms — Mama Rose is back and she’s still running this show with more sass, ambition, and emotional ballads than ever.
Gypsy remains a musical theatre masterclass about fame, family, and the fine art of passive-aggressive parenting. This revival hits all the right notes (and nerves).
Ideal for: Theater purists, drama lovers, and anyone with complicated mom feelings.
🪴 Little Shop of Horrors
Come for the doo-wop harmonies, stay for the man-eating plant. Little Shop of Horrors is back Off-Broadway and funnier than ever, proving once again that botany can be deadly. It’s campy, creepy, and endlessly quotable.
Ideal for: Sci-fi fans, horror-comedy lovers, and anyone who talks to their houseplants.
💋 Moulin Rouge! The Musical
This glitter-bomb of a show is like a Red Bull-fueled fever dream of pop hits, corsets, and doomed romance.
Moulin Rouge! mashes together Madonna, Adele, Elton John, and Lady Gaga with choreography that will have your heart racing. Prepare for sensory overload—in the best way.
Ideal for: Hopeless romantics, sparkle enthusiasts, and anyone who wishes life had a Spotify soundtrack.
🔥 The Outsiders
Stay gold, Ponyboy! This gritty, heartfelt adaptation of Outsiders, the beloved S.E. Hinton novel, brings the Greasers and the Socs to the Broadway stage with raw emotion, pulsing rock music, and teenage angst cranked to 11.
Ideal for: Literature lovers, middle school nostalgia victims, and anyone still wearing a leather jacket in July.
👑 Antony and Cleopatra
This Shakespearean epic returns with a fiery, modern twist and some of the most complex characters ever written. Antony and Cleopatra on Broadway is a tale of love, power, and absolutely no chill.
With top-tier acting and poetic battles, it’s a powerful entry in the Broadway shows NYC 2025 roster.
Ideal for: History nerds, power couple enthusiasts, and fans of tragic romance.
🎶 Mamma Mia!
Mamma Mia, here we go again — and you’ll be humming ABBA all the way home.
With its sun-drenched island vibes and disco ball dreams, this feel-good musical never fails to deliver joy, sequins, and questionable paternity. It’s the Broadway equivalent of a bottomless brunch.
Ideal for: Bachelorette parties, moms, and anyone who knows all the words to “Dancing Queen.”
💘 & Juliet
What if Juliet lived, joined a girl band, and belted out Britney Spears?
This musical flips Shakespeare on its powdered wig with a pop-packed soundtrack and a message about rewriting your own story. It’s part rom-com, part empowerment anthem, and all fun.
Ideal for: Gen Zers, pop fans, and English majors seeking revenge.
👑 Six: The Musical
The six wives of Henry VIII ditch the history books and take the stage like a royal girl group, each belting out bangers that blend Beyoncé with British history.
Six: The Musical is witty, wild, and way more fun than your AP Euro class ever was.
Ideal for: Feminists, pop music lovers, and history buffs who love drama and drama queens.
🔥 Hadestown
Who knew Greek mythology could sound like a bluesy New Orleans nightclub?
Hadestown turns the ancient tale of Orpheus and Eurydice into a toe-tapping, soul-squeezing masterpiece about love, trust, and climate change. Yes, really.
Ideal for: Mythology geeks, hopeless romantics, and folks who like their musicals with a side of jazz.
🚢 Titanique
This parody musical reimagines Titanic through the lens of Céline Dion’s power ballads and pure chaos.
It’s absurd, hilarious, and deeply committed to both historical inaccuracy and vocal acrobatics. Bring tissues — for the tears and the laughter.
Ideal for: 90s kids, Céline super-fans, and anyone who’s yelled “I’m the king of the world!” on a balcony.
💄 Death Becomes Her
Two fierce frenemies discover the secret to immortality — and fashion-forward revenge.
Based on the cult classic film, Death Becomes Her is now a campy, over-the-top musical dripping with glamour, shade, and twisted hilarity.
Ideal for: Drag fans, dark comedy lovers, and anyone who’s said “flawless” unironically.
🎷 Cabaret at the Kit Kat Club
Step into a fully immersive Berlin nightclub where everything is decadent, dangerous, and slightly unhinged.
This reimagining of Cabaret is darker, sexier, and more immersive than ever — you’re not just watching the show, you’re in it. Willkommen indeed.
Ideal for: Cabaret connoisseurs, risk-takers, and anyone who enjoys breaking the fourth wall with flair.
Whether you’re a Broadway first-timer or a seasoned theater junkie, 2025 is serving up unforgettable performances across NYC stages.
From classics like Hamilton and The Lion King to fresh hits like Hell’s Kitchen and Stranger Things, there’s no better time to score those Broadway tickets and let the magic begin.
Curtain’s up — don’t miss your moment. 🌟🎭
- Best New York Broadway Shows of 2025 - May 14, 2025
- Where Was Star Wars Filmed? Spectacular Star Wars Filming Locations - May 13, 2025
- The Most Spiritual Places in the World - May 10, 2025
Discover more from Ahoy Matey Blog
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.